B2B companies are creating more content than ever. AI tools have made it possible to pump out posts, articles, and whitepapers at unprecedented speed…but conversion rates are plummeting.

At Catalyst, we see this pattern repeatedly in our client work before they come to us. Companies add more AI tools to their stack while their content performance drops. It's like adding more engines to a boat while ignoring the hole in the bottom.

Welcome to Catalyst—your bi-weekly insights on emerging fintech and Web3 trends, a behind-the-scenes look at some of the top players in the space, and actionable strategies you can implement today. No fluff. No basic takes. Just clear insights on what's actually happening in fintech. 💻

Forwarded this email? Get Catalyst in your inbox each week.

Will’s Picks

A few things I’ve loved reading this week—

• It’s time to let go of best practices…they’re not working

• A guide to oversharing on Linkedin

• Getting press for your startup

• Digital Asset & Tokenization February roundup

• Morning Brew: Not so electric

The AI Content Paradox

Every B2B company we talk to is using AI content tools. ChatGPT, Claude, Jasper—they're collecting them like infinity stones. But their content increasingly sounds the same—Generic. Forgettable. Safe.

The problem is that companies treat AI as a replacement for strategy rather than a tool to enhance it. It's like giving someone a faster car but no destination. The speed doesn't matter if you're headed the wrong way.

This shift happened gradually. Content calendars morphed into AI prompting schedules. Editorial planning sessions became exercises in keyword optimization. The human elements—unique insights, authentic voice, genuine expertise—got squeezed out.

What Actually Works?

When we analyze successful B2B content strategies, the common thread isn't AI sophistication—it's having a clear system for extracting and amplifying genuine expertise.

We call this the Insight-First Method.

At its core, this means spending time capturing the real knowledge and unique perspectives that exist within your organization. For our clients, this takes the form of monthly extraction interviews. Sixty focused minutes with founders and subject matter experts, recording their actual experiences and insights. (I share a framework for doing these below!)

Only after we have these authentic insights do we bring in AI tools. They serve as amplifiers and accelerators—taking real expertise and adapting it for different channels and formats. 

Looking at data from our client portfolio at Catalyst, the results speak for themselves:

• Companies that start with authentic insights see engagement rates 3x higher than pure AI-generated content

• Sales teams actively share content because it reflects real expertise

• Lead quality improves because content demonstrates true understanding

Our approach at Catalyst focuses on three key elements:

True expertise comes first. We mine insights directly from founders and subject matter experts through focused extraction sessions. These form the foundation of all content.

AI enhances, not replaces. We use AI tools strategically—for research, formatting, and optimization. Never for core insights or strategic decisions.

Distribution drives results. Great content needs systematic amplification. Each piece feeds into social media, email newsletters, and sales enablement.

The Extraction Framework

Monthly insight mining with founders isn't just about asking questions.

Start with customer problems, not company features, then explore challenges through questions like:

• "What problems do customers bring up in their first call with you that they haven't been able to solve?"

• "What misconceptions do prospects have about your space that you have to correct?"

• "When customers switch to you from competitors, what's typically the final trigger?"

Look for pattern recognition. We mine insights about industry trends through questions like:

• "What change in your industry are most of your competitors missing?"

• "What's working now in your space that wasn't working 12 months ago?"

• "Where are you seeing your most sophisticated customers focus their attention?"

Document the "why" behind decisions. We uncover strategic insights through questions like:

• "What made you choose this specific approach when building your product?"

• "What's a common feature request you've decided not to build, and why?"

• "What's the biggest assumption in your industry that you're betting against?"

These questions consistently help us mine the kind of insights that separate authentic thought leadership from AI-generated noise.

Effective AI Integration

The difference between good and bad AI usage in content comes down to how you deploy it.

Here's what we've learned works:

Use AI to expand on human insights, not generate them. Once we have authentic expertise captured, we use AI to help explore different angles and applications of that knowledge.

Apply AI for format adaptation. Take one core insight and efficiently adapt it for different platforms and purposes. Build content ecosystems, not isolated assets. Each piece of content should feed into multiple channels—social media, email nurture, sales conversations. The core message stays authentic while AI helps scale distribution.

Keep humans in critical decision points. Strategy, voice, and final approval should always have human oversight. AI excels at scaling known patterns, not making judgment calls about brand and positioning.

Enable your sales team effectively. The best content in the world won't drive results if your sales team doesn't know about it or understand how to use it. We help clients build systems to get content into sales conversations naturally. Track and optimize based on sales impact, not just engagement. While social metrics matter, the real measure of B2B content success is its impact on pipeline and revenue. Build tracking systems that connect content engagement to business results.

This matters because in B2B, especially in technical industries, buyers can smell manufactured content from miles away. They're not looking for more content—they're looking for real insights from people who understand their challenges.

In an age where anyone can spin up an AI content factory, authentic expertise becomes your biggest differentiator. The tools should amplify your knowledge, not replace it.

The path forward is clear: Build your content strategy on authentic insights. Use AI to scale and enhance those insights. Focus on systematic distribution.